next up previous
Next: The NetSolve project Up: The National HPCC Software Previous: Repository Interoperation

Software Review Framework

The NHSE has designed a software review policy that enables easy access by users to information about software quality, but which is flexible enough to be used across and specialized to different disciplines. The three review levels recognized by the NHSE are the following: Unreviewed, Partially reviewed, and Reviewed. The Unreviewed designation means only that the software has been accepted into the owning repository and is thus within the scope of HPCC and of the discipline of that repository. The Partially reviewed designation means that the software has been checked by a librarian for conformance with the scope, completeness, adequate documentation, and construction guidelines. The Reviewed designation means that the software has been reviewed by an expert in the appropriate field, for example by an author of a review article in the electronic journal NHSE Review gif, and found to be of high quality. Domain-specific repositories and expert reviewers are expected to refine the NHSE software review policy by adding additional review criteria, evaluation properties, and evaluation methods and tools. The NHSE also provides for soliciting and publishing author claims and user comments about software quality. All software exported to the NHSE by its owning repository or by an individual contributor is to be tagged with its current review level and with a pointer to a review abstract which describes the software's current review status and includes pointers to supporting material.



Jack Dongarra
Thu Aug 29 16:27:43 EDT 1996